Posts

Showing posts from December, 2024

Basic physics - Chessboard of the Gods

Image
Understanding the Building Blocks of Nature: Feynman’s Perspective In the introductory chapter Basic Physics in his  Lectures on Physics , Richard Feynman offers a captivating glimpse into the goals and methods of physics. Using vivid examples and evocative metaphors, he explains how science seeks to unravel the complexity of nature by discovering its fundamental rules and principles. The Complexity of the Natural World Feynman begins by painting a rich picture of the natural world, describing a scene on a beach: the waves breaking, the foam swirling, the sand underfoot, the wind in the air, and the sun shining above. Amidst this diversity, he asks simple yet profound questions: • Is sand merely tiny stones? • Is the wind akin to water sloshing in the sea? • If we understand rocks, do we also understand sand and the moon? These questions reflect how physicists strive to connect diverse phenomena under a smaller set of fundamental principles, simplifying the apparent chaos of ...

Richard Feynman’s Teaching on Chemical Reactions

Image
Richard Feynman’s Teaching on Chemical Reactions: A Masterclass in Clarity Richard Feynman’s approach to explaining chemical reactions in his  Lectures on Physics  exemplifies his unparalleled ability to simplify complex ideas. Chapter 1 of his discussion on chemical reactions highlights his pedagogical brilliance, weaving together analogies, examples, and wit to engage readers while imparting profound scientific concepts. Pedagogical Techniques Feynman masterfully blurs the line between physical and chemical processes, inviting students to think critically about their distinctions. He directly addresses misconceptions, such as the perceived rigidity between categories, with his famous quip: “Nature does not care what we call it, she just keeps on doing it.” By focusing on conceptual clarity, he empowers students to see chemistry as a continuum rather than a collection of isolated phenomena. He balances technical detail with accessibility by breaking ideas into digestible part...

Exploring “Atomic Processes” from the Feynman Lectures

Image
The  Feynman Lectures on Physics  are a treasure trove of insights into the fundamental principles of science, delivered with a rare blend of clarity, imagination, and enthusiasm. The chapter on “Atomic Processes” from Volume 1 is no exception. It delves into the behaviour of matter on an atomic scale, transforming everyday phenomena like evaporation, dissolution, and crystallisation into vivid, dynamic processes. Here, we explore the principles, examples, and teaching strategies that classroom science educators can glean from Richard Feynman’s approach. Principles Explored in “Atomic Processes” 1. Dynamic Equilibrium Feynman explains equilibrium as a balance of ongoing processes, such as evaporation and condensation. He illustrates how molecules constantly move between liquid and gaseous phases, even when no visible change occurs—a dynamic “nothing happens” state. 2. Energy Exchange in Evaporation He highlights the role of energy in evaporation. Molecules that escape the ...

Exploring Infinite Divisibility: Mathematics, Metaphysics, and the Nature of Matter - with Einstein

Image
The question of whether matter is infinitely divisible or fundamentally granular has intrigued thinkers for centuries. Philosophers like Leibniz and Herbart, alongside mathematicians like Poisson, have contributed significantly to this debate, proposing that matter either consists of indivisible “monads” or can be broken down infinitely into smaller parts. Einstein’s reflections offer a critical lens through which to evaluate these ideas. Einstein quotes Herbart approvingly, stating,  “It is wrong that matter ultimately consists of matter again; its true components are simple (simple beings, substances, monads).”  This argument emphasises that the infinite divisibility of matter leads to an unsolvable paradox: if matter were endlessly divisible, we would never reach a fundamental “last part.” Einstein critiques this idea as a limitation of human thought rather than a reflection of physical reality, suggesting that such a division is a mathematical abstraction rather than a met...

Demonstrating Conservation of Mass with Potassium Iodide and Lead Nitrate

Image
One of the highlights in our recent science lesson was demonstrating the conservation of mass using the reaction between potassium iodide and lead nitrate. This chemical reaction is perfect for illustrating this principle, as it creates a dramatic visual effect: when the two colourless solutions are mixed, a bright yellow precipitate of lead(II) iodide forms almost instantly. The students, especially the girls in my class, were captivated by the reaction, as its rapid, vivid result made the abstract concept of conservation of mass tangible and memorable. The beauty of this experiment lies in its simplicity and effectiveness. Unlike reactions that produce gases, which may escape and complicate mass measurements, this reaction generates a solid product. This allows us to weigh the reactants and the final mixture to confirm that no mass is lost—just redistributed as a new compound forms. Safety was a top priority during the experiment. Since lead compounds are toxic, we performed the reac...

Einstein’s earliest writings

Image
In 1881, 12 year old Albert Einstein was absorbed in a book about geometry (Lehrbuch der Geometrie zum Gebrauche an höheren Lehranstalten. Von Eduard Heis und Thomas Joseph Eschweiler) - a text that no modern twelve year old would read. On p76 something struck the young Einstein and he felt compelled to annotate his geometry book with what now stands as his earliest surviving writing.  The text (on p76 of the book) describes the concept of a cylindrical surface as one that can be “developed” or unrolled into a plane. By considering the cylinder’s side as formed by a sequence of planes, one can imagine these planes rotating around their edges until they align flat with neighboring planes. This process divides the cylinder’s surface into prismatic spaces, whose lateral surfaces can similarly flatten. As the number of planes increases, these prismatic surfaces approximate the cylinder, showing how its geometry can be represented in a plane. Einstein, then adds in the side margin “Der ...

Energy stores - GCSE physics

Image
Today, we’re going to talk about energy. Energy is the first module of the AQA GCSE Physics syllabus, and that is where we’re going to start. If you asked a physicist what energy was, the very first thing they might do is pause for a significant second. They’d have trouble telling you—not due to a lack of understanding but because it’s challenging to explain something so complex in simple terms. Energy is a bit like the animal kingdom. There are different types of energy, and they are each very different from one another. Creating an overarching explanation or description for all of it is one of the challenges physicists face. But what actually  is  energy? Energy is a quantity that we can measure. It carries the unit of the joule. Energy is the “family name” for a whole range of phenomena, and it works like any other measurable quantity in physics. Nearly 100 years ago, Albert Einstein came to a startling conclusion about energy: energy and matter are two facets of the same t...

The First Point of Aries

Image
Running a school astronomy club has been one of the most rewarding experiences of my teaching career. The girls in the club are endlessly curious, particularly about the intricate relationships between the Earth, Sun, and Moon. Their questions often take us on fascinating tangents—from the phases of the Moon to the mechanics of eclipses. One discussion, however, stood out. While exploring the paths of celestial objects, we touched on the idea of the  vernal equinox  and the shifting position of the Sun in the sky over millennia. This sparked my own reflection on a lesser-known but pivotal concept in astronomy: the  First Point of Aries , a point that links humanity’s understanding of the cosmos to the slow, majestic movements of Earth’s axis. This led me to consider the broader context of Earth’s celestial mechanics and the astronomical “ages” that unfold over tens of thousands of years. These are vast timescales that connect us to the stars and offer a humbling perspecti...

Feynman - Matter is made of atoms

Image
This passage from the  Feynman Lectures on Physics  masterfully explains the atomic hypothesis—the idea that all matter consists of tiny, perpetually moving particles called atoms. It uses vivid imagery, analogies, and clear scientific explanations to convey fundamental principles of physics, making it a rich resource for science education. Key Ideas and Laws of Physics 1. Atomic Hypothesis : • Feynman identifies the atomic hypothesis as the most informative statement in science: “all things are made of atoms—little particles that move around in perpetual motion, attracting each other when slightly apart, but repelling upon being squeezed together.” • This sentence encapsulates fundamental concepts about matter, forces, and motion. 2. Structure of Matter : • Atoms are extremely small, measured in angstroms (10⁻⁸ cm). A magnified analogy equates atoms to the size of original apples if the apple were as large as the Earth. • Molecules consist of atoms bound together; for inst...

What does your digital footprint say about you? This is what Grok knew about me.

Image
Exploring the Educational Horizons with Dr. David Boyce: A Physics Teacher's Vision In the realm of physics education, few names resonate with as much enthusiasm and innovation as Dr. David Boyce. An award-winning teacher, textbook author, and a dynamic presence in the physics community, Dr. Boyce has carved a niche for himself with his unique educational philosophy. Here, we delve into his innovative teaching methods, his advocacy for inclusivity, and his contributions to physics education. A Champion for Inclusive Physics Education Dr. Boyce has been a vocal advocate for an inclusive approach to teaching physics. His perspective, shared on platforms like X, emphasizes that the role of educators transcends encouraging specific demographics into the subject. He argues against pigeonholing female physics teachers into roles solely focused on encouraging girls into the field, stating, "We need to stop telling female prospective teachers of physics that they will be excellent at ...

Schrödinger’s Cat - From Clockwork to Quantum: Newton’s Legacy and the Dawn of Uncertainty

Image
Introduction This analysis delves into John Gribbin’s  In Search of Schrödinger’s Cat , exploring his use of imagery, analogies, and explanatory devices to demystify scientific concepts. Focusing on the opening chapter, Gribbin masterfully blends narrative with scientific explanation, illustrating the transition from Newtonian mechanics to quantum physics. By breaking down abstract ideas into relatable terms, he offers readers an accessible yet profound understanding of the evolution of modern science. Summary of the Excerpt 1. Newton’s Contributions and Scientific Legacy Gribbin begins by highlighting Isaac Newton’s foundational role in physics, which paved the way for centuries of scientific advancement. Newton’s three laws of motion and his law of gravity established the framework for classical mechanics and shaped our understanding of the physical world. Gribbin notes that while 20th-century quantum mechanics has transcended Newton’s theories, his early investigations—particu...

The Feynman lectures. A study - part I

Image
The  Feynman Lectures on Physics  remain a towering achievement in the education of physicists, combining clarity, wit, and a profound curiosity about the natural world. Since my days studying physics at Lancaster University a quarter of a century ago, I have found this seminal text endlessly inspiring and challenging. Its brilliance lies not only in its exploration of physical principles but also in its approach to scientific thinking, which transcends formulae and experiments. These reflections are a personal journey—a collection of thoughts meant to revisit the  Lectures , written primarily for my own understanding. They are not a critique but an attempt to distil the enduring fascination and insight Feynman’s work continues to evoke. Analysis The Nature of Scientific Knowledge 1. Summarising Complex Ideas Despite centuries of scientific progress, the vast accumulation of knowledge can often be distilled into a set of fundamental laws. However, these laws are rarely ...